Why is the decision harder than it looks?
Operating partners often cover several portfolio companies, while management teams must deliver transformation alongside their day jobs. At a London private equity event in October 2026, one participant described a small functional team supporting a portfolio of around 40 businesses. This was an individual conference observation, not a market benchmark.
McKinsey’s 2021 research found that fewer than one in three transformations achieved and sustained improved performance, with the largest share of potential value lost during implementation. That does not mean every portfolio company needs external advisers. It does underline the importance of managing execution as a distinct challenge.
Five warning signs worth acting on
- The same initiatives miss successive milestones even though monthly financial results remain satisfactory.
- Two or three executives own most of the value creation agenda alongside demanding operational responsibilities.
- Cross-functional decisions can only be unlocked by the CEO, creating a persistent bottleneck.
- Reports describe meetings, activities and traffic-light statuses, but not a credible impact on EBITDA, cash flow, service quality or productivity.
- The business has limited experience of delivering several complex changes at once.
Two or more signs can justify a focused review; they are not a validated threshold or an automatic reason to hire outside help. The first task is to establish whether the constraint lies in management capacity, capabilities, accountability or the underlying initiative.
Diagnose the constraint before adding resources
Start with the agreed value creation plan, the actual workload of the initiative owners and the decisions that have stalled across functions. If the business case remains sound but the team lacks capacity or coordination, focused execution support can be an effective response.
If the team has sufficient time yet lacks critical skills, questions the initiative’s assumptions or faces materially changed market conditions, adding more people may not help. Those issues belong with management and the fund as owners of the existing plan. External delivery support should not be presented as an automatic strategy reset.
What should the engagement brief include?
A useful engagement buys outcomes, not simply consultant days. Five points should be agreed before work begins:
- Outcomes: which agreed initiatives are to be delivered, the expected business impact and how it will be measured.
- Accountability: the management sponsor, delivery owner and person who will take ownership when external support ends.
- Decision-making: the weekly delivery forum, management reviews and escalation to the operating partner or board.
- Authority: what the external team can decide and what requires approval from company leadership.
- Handover: the end date, processes and capabilities that must remain in the company.
The operating partner’s role should also be explicit: constructive challenger, sounding board or active sponsor in clearing obstacles. Ambiguity here creates parallel lines of management.
What should be different after 100 days?
The first hundred days is a useful first review point, not a promise of financial return. Some initiatives may already show a measurable impact; others will still be laying the foundations for later benefits.
The operating partner should nevertheless expect a shorter list of genuine priorities, clearly named owners, credible milestones, decisions taken at a regular cadence and initial evidence of progress against a baseline.
If responsibilities remain unclear and deadlines simply move again, the original diagnosis should be challenged. The issue may be more fundamental than a lack of capacity.
Three mistakes to avoid
- Do not send several functional experts into a company without a shared mandate and a single point of contact.
- Do not create another reporting layer that consumes management time without speeding up decisions.
- Do not mistake billable days for delivered value.
The real test is whether the company can continue delivering the agreed plan more effectively once the external team has left.
A practitioner’s perspective
Having worked in private equity-owned businesses, I have experienced two very different kinds of external support. The best helped resolve decisions, took on defined work and gradually transferred ownership back to the management team. The least effective created more meetings. You can usually see the difference in the first few weeks.
The takeaway: Bring in execution support when it enables management to deliver the agreed value creation plan, not when it displaces management accountability. Define the outcome, owner, measure of success and handover from the outset.
Sources and further reading
McKinsey & Company (2021), Losing from day one: Why even successful transformations fall short. Read the study
